Navbar button The Headteacher

Academy Trust Handbook 2026 – Implications for executive pay

November 16, 2026, 10:53 GMT+1
Read in 8 minutes
  • The rules on academy trust executive pay have changed – here’s what board members and school leaders need to know
Academy Trust Handbook 2026 – Implications for executive pay

Executive pay in academy trusts has long attracted public attention.

Headlines about six-figure salaries can generate scrutiny that lands on the desk of even the most scrupulous board, and many governors will know the uncomfortable feeling of defending a pay decision that is entirely reasonable but looks difficult when context is stripped away.

That world has not gone away but since changes came into effect on 1 October 2026, it has acquired a new and much more demanding regulatory layer.

New guidance

The Academy Trust Handbook 2026 represents a fundamental shift in how executive pay decisions must be made, documented and approved. The Department for Education (DfE) says it has observed instances where executive pay and annual increases have diverged significantly from those of teachers and of peers across the wider public sector. The new regime is designed to close that gap.

What has actually changed?

There are two headline obligations, both mandatory as a condition of funding.

Pre-advertisement approval

Any new appointment where total remuneration exceeds £174,000 – or the pro-rata equivalent for part-time staff – or where performance-related pay exceeds £25,000, requires DfE approval before the post is even advertised.

This is not a tick-box exercise. The DfE will assess applications against a range of criteria, including the complete pay package, the influence and impact of the role, relevant benchmarking data, trust-specific factors such as size and Ofsted outcomes, and labour market considerations.

Crucially, the guidance is explicit that boards should consider how a salary could withstand public scrutiny and whether it can be publicly justified.

Pay growth constraint

Executive remuneration must not increase at a faster rate than the trust’s own teacher pay award, unless there is clear justification. The teacher pay increase from September 2026 is 3.5%, plus teachers could move up a point in the pay range. each trust should calculate the average teacher pay increase of all its teachers and compare that to the average pay increase for its executives.

Any proposed executive pay increase that exceeds the average increase for teachers in the trust – requires advance DfE approval, not merely a documented rationale. The comparison is trust-specific: it is the increase awarded to your trust’s own teaching staff that matters, not a sector-wide figure.

What counts as a ‘new appointment’?

One of the most important and widely misunderstood aspects of the new regime is how broadly ‘new appointment’ is defined. It is not limited to external hires. It covers external recruits, appointments to newly created roles, promotions, and lateral moves into existing roles within the trust.

If an internal candidate is promoted into a role attracting a salary above £174,000, DfE approval is required before the post is advertised. Boards that have assumed otherwise need to revisit their succession plans immediately.

The accounting officer risk

There is a governance risk embedded in the new rules that has attracted almost no commentary – but it should be on every board’s agenda.

Every academy trust must have an accounting officer in post at all times. That obligation does not pause while the DfE processes an approval application. Where a chief executive’s departure is anticipated – or, worse, where it is unexpected – the sequencing challenge is acute.

Before a replacement can even be advertised, the trust should complete benchmarking work, obtain full board approval, and submit a DfE application. The DfE expects trusts to allow a minimum of 20 working days for a decision. Only then can recruitment begin, with an advertisement, a selection process, and a notice period for the successful candidate that could itself run to six months.

The problem is sharpest where a chief executive remains employed on a headteacher’s contract. Those notice periods were designed for a world in which a school could appoint a new head within a single academic cycle. They are entirely incompatible with the timescales the approval regime now demands.

If you have not reviewed the terms of your most senior executive’s contract with this in mind, do so now before a vacancy arises.

Why the evidence base matters more than ever

Good intentions are not enough. What the DfE approval process demands is evidence – and that evidence needs to be built before it is needed, not assembled under pressure once a vacancy exists.

Pay ratios are essential tools for demonstrating proportionality. Three metrics are useful: executive pay expressed as a cost per academy; total executive remuneration as a per-pupil cost; and executive pay as a percentage of total income.

The Confederation of School Trusts 2026 benchmarking report, published in partnership with Brightmine and Browne Jacobson, contains useful proportionality benchmarks that trusts can compare with their own data.

These ratios illustrate whether pay is proportionate to the scale and complexity of the organisation. A chief executive earning £500,000 may well have a lower cost per pupil than one earning £180,000 in a much smaller trust. Context is what will really matter here.

Backing up your decisions

Benchmarking is critical. It is not enough to present a dataset showing where a proposed salary sits relative to sector comparators.

The board must be able to explain, in documented form, why those comparators are appropriate. Why that peer group has been selected, what characteristics of the trust justify the benchmarks chosen, and how the salary proposed reflects the specific role and responsibilities in question.

Benchmarking data without a rationale is a number looking for a justification. Benchmarking data with a clear documented rationale is evidence of robust governance.

Five actions your trust board should take now

Review the notice periods for all senior executive staff. Where the chief executive or other senior executives remain on headteacher contracts, those provisions are almost certainly incompatible with the new approval timescales. Take legal advice on how this can be addressed.

Commission up-to-date benchmarking for all executive roles now, not when a vacancy arises. A pre-existing, rigorous benchmarking report removes a time-consuming step from an already compressed process when you need it most.

Map your planned pay review against the growth constraint. Before the next executive pay review cycle, carry out a gap analysis comparing total planned pay movement against the equivalent movement for your teaching workforce. The combined picture on both sides is what matters.

Audit all pay above £174,000, including headteacher salaries, for defensibility, proportionality and transparency. For context, L43 in Inner London is £158,863 for the current academic year, with a maximum headteacher salary of £198,578.75 in exceptional circumstances when section 2, paragraph 10 of the School Teachers’ Pay and Conditions statutory guidance is engaged. Any salary above the threshold needs a clearly documented rationale.

Plan your succession proactively. Because internal moves now trigger the approval requirement, boards should not wait for a departure to be announced before beginning the approval process. Know now where the approval threshold might be crossed and prepare accordingly.

Robust processes are key

The boards that will navigate this regime most confidently are those that have already invested in robust processes – rigorous pay-setting, documented rationale, independent scrutiny and regular benchmarking.

For them, an approval application should be a relatively straightforward exercise. The challenge is greatest for those who have not built that evidence base, and who will find themselves assembling it from scratch against a recruitment clock that is already running.

Emma Hughes is a Partner and Head of HR Services at Browne Jacobson, where she leads the firm’s education HR, employment and governance advisory work for academy trusts.