Navbar button The Headteacher
May 21 BigDug
May 21 BigDug

Are you a School Leader or a Manager?

May 26, 2019, 8:47 GMT+1
Read in 4 minutes
  • Catherine Carden considers the difference between ‘leadership’ and ‘management’ – and whether the distinction matters...
Are you a School Leader or a Manager?

Leadership within primary education is something that’s regularly debated, discussed and judged, be it through Ofsted inspections, local newspaper reports, national news stories or social media posts.

What does that term ‘leadership’ actually mean? Is it a more contemporary term for what used to be referred to as ‘management’? Or is there more to it than that?

‘Leadership’ is a term that all of us regularly use within everyday conversation, but if put on the spot and asked to define the word, most of us would find that quite a struggle. Some will offer a fairly simple definition, such as this concise example found on the pages of “The activity of leading a group of people or an organisation, or the ability to do this.”

Others will argue that leadership is, in fact, a far more complex notion that has a variety of definitions. That complexity often results in definitions of leadership morphing into a list of skills and attributes of effective leaders. However, this difficulty in defining leadership shouldn’t be seen as problematic, but rather an acknowledgement of how leadership is, in fact, a highly nuanced, multi-layered concept.

Organisational objectives

Management, on the other hand, is a much more easily definable term that centres around the process of attaining organisational objectives through effective co-ordination of resources and activity within a hierarchical structure.

The terms ‘management’ and ‘leadership’ will often be used interchangeably, with some referring to themselves as being ‘part of the management team’, or even ‘a manager’, while others will cite the presence of a ‘leadership team’ and consider themselves as being ‘a leader’.

Leadership and management aren’t the same thing and shouldn’t be conflated. Effective leaders need be aware of the difference, and should be able to articulate it to their teams through their actions.

‘Management’ is characterised by task-oriented activities, such as writing reports, producing action plans, managing emails and various other administrative tasks.

‘Leadership’ is strategic, and will involve tasks such as enhancing teaching and learning, and feeding analysis and evaluation into priorities for development.

Most among you will likely aspire more towards the latter than the former, but probably concede that the majority of your time has become dominated by management tasks.

Quick results

The process of moving from being a task-orientated manager to becoming a strategic leader requires time, determination and a willingness to make difficult and bold decisions, underpinned by a strong understanding of what it means to lead, rather than manage.

Yet despite leadership and management being very different, the two aren’t mutually exclusive. Leadership roles inevitably entail a range of management tasks that have to be undertaken. What’s important is that leaders are able to identify when they’re spending too much time on management tasks, to the detriment of leadership activities.

Given the widespread pressure to achieve quick results and immediate impact, even the most well-intentioned leaders risk losing direction and focus, causing management concerns to trump leadership aims.

Yet if a school’s results and impact are to be sustainable in the long-term, only strong leadership will deliver that. Developing a clear knowledge and understanding of leadership, and investing time in learning how to practice it well, will ultimately pay dividends for any headteacher and their school.

Catherine Carden is the faculty director of primary initial teacher education at Canterbury Christ Church University.